Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Haadee al-Madkhalee on the Reality of Daesh (ISIS)

Questioner: May Allah show goodness towards you; There has been an abundant of criticism on what has been known as Daesh, and all praises belong to Allah. However, the problem is that the majority of people in this time do not know their origin and they do not know their sources, and who they separated from. Rather, you find some who attribute them, meaning those who bomb and blow up things, they attribute to them that they are merely youth, or that they have (peer) pressure (from others), or it is because of unemployment, or magic (has been placed on them), and they say other than that, so what do you advise regarding this, may Allah preserve you.

Answer: Daesh, and what will make you know who are Daesh?! Daesh is an acronym. Some say (the acronym) is like the language of engraving, just as the ant engraves within a seed until it becomes hollow and empty. So this is the language of engraving. Daesh named themselves, and they formed for themselves this acronym, this abbreviated nickname, and it befits them. They call themselves al Dawlah al Islamiyyah Fi al Iraq wa Sham (i.e. Islamic State in Iraq and Sham). So they took the letter Daal د from the word al-Dawlah, and the letter Alif after the Daal, دا stands for Islamiyyah, and the letter Ain داع stands for Iraq , and the letter Sheen stands for Sham. So it was called as an acronym داعش Daesh, meaning al-Dawlah al-Islamiyyah Fi al-Iraq wa Sham; but they have absolutely nothing to do with Islam, and Islam is free from them.

We have not seen anyone in this era equal to them in criminality, nor have we heard in history anyone like them except the Tartars, in what they are upon from their actions, savagery, wickedness, and their inflicting punishment upon the people of Islam. This group, the group Daesh is a miscarriage whom Allah decreed they live, as a test and trial from Allah for the Ummah of Islam. And this group emerged from the belly of al-Khawwan al-Muslimeen (i.e. the deceivers of the Muslims) (which are) the Ikhwanul-Muslimeen; they emerged from them. Their founding mother is this group, and they split away from al-Qaeda, so all of their origins is al-Qaeda; al-Qaeda anil-Khayr [1] (those who sit back and do no good), (but) strive towards evil; (the group) which was formed in Afghanistan following the war [2]. Then, their leadership was transferred, after Abdullah Azzam to Bin Laden, and after Bin Laden to Ayman al-Thawahiri.

Ayman al-Thawahiri was from where? He was from Egypt, a member of the Jama’ah al-Islamiyyah and he was imprisoned after the killing of (Anwar) el-Sadat. Afterwards he was released, then joined what was occurring in Afghanistan at that time. However, he was from the Jama’ah which occurred from it that which occurred from bombings in those early days in Egypt, in the 1970’s and then in the 1980’s.

So Ayman al-Thawahiri was given the pledge of allegiance (as leader) of al-Qa’eda after his predecessor, Usamah bin Laden. Then, when the war started in Sham, [3] that which took place occurred (from tribulation), and I do not want to branch off speaking about the different groups fighting there in Syria, because by Allah, who there is no deity besides Him, I Know each of them, group by group; and if I spoke to you all about each group there would not be enough time, but what concerns us now is this branch (Daesh). So then Jabhat al-Nusrah appeared after everyone initially flocked (to Syria) in order to unite, when they first gathered to fight against the Syrian government who are Nusayri [4] (in belief). So this (group) Jabhat al-Nusrah shaped, as they say, the Islamic wave, or the Islamic movement, but in reality they were part of the al-Qa’eda organization. Perhaps many of you have heard that they openly pledged allegiance to al-Qa’eda, to al-Thawahiri. Then differences arose between them, so the group Daesh split from them. When this split occurred, separation occurred. This group had their Imam they already had pledged allegiance to, so how would anyone follow them (Daesh) and they had no leader?

So they elected for themselves a leader, this Majhool (unknown individual) (Abu Bakr) al Baghdadi. They appeared to unite around him, but in reality the issue is not al-Baghdadi, but there is something (more sinister) behind this, he is only a prop and a presence. But in reality, behind him are leaderships from the takfiri groups who came from Afghanistan. So when they scattered and split up throughout the earth after the incident of September (11th), a reason came for them by which they found an opportunity to unite again, so the affair of Iraq occurred and the tribulations that happened with it. And then the tribulations that happened in Sham followed by way of what they called “the Arab Spring”; but we didn’t see sunshine, we didn’t see except evil, and this is something I always say. So this group took shape (i.e. Daesh), and the deviant individuals of takfir from every place flocked to them. Also, they possess the ability to use media (i.e. videos, social media etc), which allows them to lure individuals more than anyone else like them, because of their ability to use the media, so they succeeded in this aspect.

Likewise, they are a melting pot of people, from Arabs and non-Arabs, and what unites them is the takfiri ideology. So this group took shape, and before, they were weaker than (Jabhat) al-Nusrah. Then they gained strength by gaining assistance from those whom are not hidden from the one who is intelligent. Then, there is what occurred from collusion between them and between the Rafidah. Because they, the Rafidah, are those who aided them in the beginning, up until they were handed over the town of Mosul. I used to say this long ago, in the beginning of their affair, and what’s happening today affirms that. So the one who steps back to hand over to them Mosul for Tehran has established close ties, and what was once hidden became apparent. So they handed over to them this major army base which is in the town of Mosul, the second biggest city in Iraq, and they took it and everything that was in it, and by it they gained strength. They had with them a number of people from Iraq who knew how to use those weapons, and others who had training on how to use those weapons in Afghanistan; so by this they gained strength. After this, what occurred for them took place, from their gaining control over some sources of wealth, and this was by robbing banks, and taking control of some of the Iraqi oil fields; and those who needed oil bought from them for cheap prices on the black market.

So they (Daesh) didn’t lose, and those who bought it didn’t lose, as they profited by purchasing crude oil for a very cheap price. So they (Daesh) benefited from these profits they made, without them having to toil or put in any hard work at all. So again they gain strength by this, and they grew in number and they grew in equipment and resources and reached the point that they reached. So now, when the Takfiris in the Arab and Islamic world saw that strength was in their favor, the favor of Daesh; this wicked group that Islam has not been afflicted in recent times with anyone more wicked than them. So when they saw this strength, from the people were those who were sick (in ideology), and their time came to let out what they held in their chest, so they joined them. And from the people were those who were of feeble intellect who perhaps used to be laughed at, so they lured this type through their media, and thus they traveled to them. And I say, commenting on some speech that came about out of envy; that which came in the question of the brother, that some people only joined them because of lack of employment; I say, ok and some people left to join them and their monthly salary was 15,000 (Saudi Riyals). Did he go because of unemployment? Huh? Why did he go? Because of a creed; their hearts are filled with hatred, rancor, and envy against the people of Islam, we ask Allah’s protection from that. How many people went to them who have high positions of employment? They didn’t go to them because of unemployment, but this is only weakness in religion, and them being overtaken by the devils. Even women went to them, either initially or either later on. Either they followed their male relatives, or went initially because they were upon deviation from their foundation, just like the women of the Khawarij from old.

‘Imran ibn Hittan married a woman from the Khawarij and when he was advised he said I’m going to guide her (to what’s correct), but she caused him to deviate. Up until the point she praised the one who killed Ali (radiyallaahu ‘anhu)(then the Shaykh mentions some poetry she said praising the one who killed Ali, and from what she said praising him that he):

“Only did this to reach the pleasure of the Owner of the throne” and “Indeed I mention him some days and I deem him to be the most hopeful of creation for a good judgment before Allah.”

Is the one who killed Ali the most hopeful of creation for a good judgement before Allah? I seek Allah’s refuge from that. The one who killed Uthman (radiyallaahu ‘anhu), when he cut off his head he began to shake it and roll it with the end of his sword and said “I have not seen the face of a Kafir better than this”! Uthman ibn ‘Afffan, chief of the believers, the one who the angels of the Lord of the creation had shyness of, the one whom the Messenger (H)married two of his daughters to and said “If I had a third I would have married you to her”, and he said “It doesn’t harm Uthman what he does after today”, and he said “Who will prepare the army of hardship [5] and for him will be Jannah”. And he said “Who will buy the Rumah well and for him will be Jannah [6].” So, the Prophet said about Uthman what he said from praise and laudation, and this criminal says “I have not seen the face of a Kafir better than this”! Those (Khawarij), whom  Uthman or Ali (radiyallaahu ‘anhumaa) were not safe from, do you expect the Islamic lands of today to be safe from them?! So this is from another angle. A third angle, and this is unfortunate that we hear this; people say “Our children”, yes, it’s true they are our children, our children in lineage, but those who go to them are not sons of ours!

(Here the Shaykh mentions some poetry in this regard)

The Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) said (describing the Khawarij) “They have young teeth” what does he mean? They are young (in age), right or wrong? “Foolish in thought”, meaning their intellects are immature. Whoever is young in age, they are young in intellect, O gathering of youth. As for the old man, the world has come upon him because of his old age, and he has gained experience, and he has grown away from being rash, so how about if this is coupled with having knowledge (of Islam)? Beloved ones, there is something that I wish to say to you, and I have said it before, and it is a sad reality and I am directing my speech tonight to my sons from the youth. This is considering that they are still impressionable and their knowledge is limited, specifically those who do not have a background in Islamic knowledge.

I say O my beloved ones, before if we used to see a person wearing the beard, and listen carefully, because this is not in any way to defame the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), however as a warning from those who fall into this; if we saw a person wearing the beard and shortening the thawb upon the Sunnah, we would be happy because of that, and we would be happy if we saw our children accompanying them. We would say, this one is upon good! But now, O my beloved ones, do not be deceived by outward appearance, until you know what that person is upon. Do not be deceived by the beard, yes it a Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), however, these individuals (i.e. Daesh and the Takfiris) have used it for deception. Also, do not be deceived because of the shortening of the thawb. A person may say, O Muhammad Bin Hadi, are you defaming the Sunnah? I will be in a great state of loss if I did that; that is apostasy from the religion of Allah. However, nothing caused me to say this except to warn (from the people of innovation), and I have Salaf in this. And it suffices me in boasting is that it is from the Imam of the Imams, the Salafi, Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal.

This is when it was said to him regarding Harith al-Muhasibi, that he narrates Hadeeth, having humbleness, being tranquil; O my sons, and I specify the youth, pay attention to my words, may Allah preserve you all. They said to Imam Ahmad when he spoke against Harith al-Muhasibi, they said O Abu Abdillah (i.e. Imam Ahmad), he (al-Muhasibi) narrates Hadeeth, the Hadeeth of who? Answer me? The Hadeeth of the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), with humbleness, tranquility, and he was a pious worshiper. So he said, may Allah have mercy upon him, “Do not let Harith deceive you, not the lowering of his head (out of humbleness) nor the long length of his beard, nor his narrating of Hadeeth”, and in another wording from Ahmad (he said) “Is everyone who narrates the Hadeeth of the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) to be sat with?! No, and there is no apology (for what I say), that is an evil man. No one knows him except the one who has become fully acquainted with him.” Ahmad was fully acquainted with him. Listen to the reason my beloved ones. He said, “So and so and so and so sat with him”. He didn’t name those who sat with him, just like now you may know some people and do not want to mention them in order to cover their faults. He said “so and so sat with him and he caused them to adopt the opinion of Yaqub al-Mughazili and the opinion of Jahm (ibn Safwan), so they became destroyed because of him”. Do not be deceived by his long beard or the lowering of his head appearing to be a worshiper, nor his abundant crying and humility, nor him narrating the hadeeth of the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), no. So O youth, do not suffice with the long length of one’s beard and the shortness of his thawb, until you know his speech and his ideology, and that he is upon the Sunnah. If you do not, they (may) cause you to adopt the opinion of Daesh. This is one matter; secondly I go back and I say, not everyone who lets his beard grow is a member of Daesh, no by Allah.

However, O my beloved ones, advice necessitates that I mention this to you. So do not be deceived by outward appearance, until you test he who is speaking and until you know what his ideology is. This is because these are our children; these are our beloved children amongst us and between us, walking these lands; these are our children, so we have to diligently look after them. Now you see one of them, nineteen years of age and he blows himself up; nineteen years old and he blows up Masjids; eighteen, twenty years old, what is this? The cause, is this wicked Daesh ideology. By Allah (tell me), people who are praying, they are praying an obligation from the obligations Allah placed upon them; and who are those (praying)? They are soldiers who go out exerting themselves (to protect the land) while we relax. They keep us safe with the safety granted by Allah the Exalted and High; they are at our service. They are killed while they’re in prostration? By Allah, even the disbelievers of old never did this, except one group of them who breached a covenant, and it was the cause that the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) went out for the conquest of Makkah. And the story is that during the expedition of al-Hudaybiyah, some individuals from (the tribe) of al-Khuza’ah entered a treaty with him, and (the tribe) of Banu Bakr entered a treaty with the Quraysh, so they breached the treaty of the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) with Quraysh because they were helpers of Quraysh and they laid in ambush for al-Khuza’ah. So ‘Amr ibn Salim came and said (the Shaykh quotes lines of poetry said by ‘Amr indicating the breach of the pact by Banu Bakr and their treachery, and from that which he said):

“And they killed us whilst in Rukoo’ and in Sujood.”

So the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) said,

“Indeed you will be given help O ‘Amr ibn Salim.”

So he (the Prophet) commanded with the preparation of the army of the conquest, and they proceeded until they conquered Makkah. This was the only event in history where people killed those praying. The Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam) said, “I have been prevented from killing those praying”. These people, my dear brothers, kill people who pray, and they see this to be from the highest forms of Jihad in Allah’s cause. Is this considered Jihad? This is corruption! We seek Allah’s refuge from that. If the Fitrah is reversed, and the intellects are brainwashed, we seek Allah’s refuge from that. O my beloved ones, O my sons, O youth, do not be deceived by these individuals. You’ve seen these individuals, they swing the heads of the Muslims like the heads of sheep are swung. They burn people, is this, by Allah, from Islam? With all of this, the disbelieving lands said that ten years is needed to eradicate them (i.e. Daesh). Masha’Allah, you eradicated Afghanistan in six months, a whole land in its entirety. What does this show? It shows collusion between these individuals. So O brothers in Islam, this is the reality of Daesh in summary. So beware of the members of Daesh, the Dawahish (i.e. the infiltrators) that have crept in upon us. By Allah, if I knew that one of my children was upon this ideology I would fight him tooth and nail (to return him to the truth), and if I couldn’t, by Allah, the one who there is no deity in truth besides He, I would take him and surrender him to the authorities. I would surrender him to the authorities so they can treat him and he can be cured and become healthy (i.e. upon a sound ideology), while I still can see him, is more beloved to me than he travel to them.

A person related to me a story about a cousin of his; his son left, and he didn’t realize until he was already with Daesh. When he got there he (the son) called. I know the individual but I don’t want to mention his name, (he is) in Madinah. He said to him “O my son come back, why’d you go”? The son replied “InshaAllah I’m coming back to you, you will know, I will show you the right of Allah”. He said “What is it that you saw in us”? He said “I will show you that you all are Kuffar”! He (the father) said “We are Kuffar and you were the one who used to push me in the wheel chair to the masjid [7]”. He (the son) said: “This is the Islam of the hypocrites (that you are upon), and I will be soon returning to you InshaAllah” (i.e. said as a threat). He (the father) hung up the phone and let him be. Look at this evil speech and look at what degree (of evil) this undutiful son has reached. So O my beloved ones, beware of these internet sites on these computers by which these people can enter upon you. Beware of this at all costs. By Allah, that one goes and sings and plays the lute [8] is more beloved to me than he goes to those individuals. This is because if he sings and plays the lute or drinks intoxicants, by Allah he will never attribute this to Islam. All of you (in front of me) if you asked one of them right now (i.e. who sings or drinks etc.) what would they reply? They’ll say “Ask Allah to guide me O shaykh”. Right or wrong? (The brothers respond) “Right”. Would they attribute this evil of theirs to the religion? (Some respond) “No”. It is not possible that they attribute intoxicants to the religion. It is not possible that they attribute intoxicants to the religion, except he who has become blind in his insight, but rather they will say “Supplicate to Allah that he guides us”. But these (members of Daesh) say “You are a Kafir and may Allah guide you”! Guide you to what? To rebellion and to their wicked methodology they are upon. The Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam)said, O gathering of youth, regarding these individuals “They are young in age, foolish in thought, they utter the statements of the best of mankind (i.e. the Prophet), but they will exit the religion just as the arrow goes through the game”. They try to use proof the statements of the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam), but they are far away from it, and they exit the religion quickly, just as an arrow passes through a hunted animal, then they do not return to it, as the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam)said.

And he said “Glad tiding to whoever they kill or whomever is killed by them; indeed whoever kills them has a reward, and indeed whoever is killed by them has a reward. If I was to reach them I would kill them just as the people of ‘Ad were killed.” Is there anything clearer than this speech O my beloved ones? These people deem permissible the blood of the Muslims. In the time of the companions when Ibn ‘Abbas (radiyallaahu ‘anhu) went to them to debate them, they sat there speaking about him, saying “And you O Ibn ‘Abbas..”, and he was wearing a new cloak. Ibn ‘Abbas said “I saw the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam),wearing a cloak better than this. Today, they (i.e. the Khawarij) have the same speech; they say the scholars are scholars who wear Bishts [9]. What do they really have against them? (The truth) is because they are not upon their methodology. So Ibn ‘Abbas said to them, and he refuted them triumphantly, he said “I came to you from the companions of the Messenger of Allah (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam),and I do not see amongst you even one of them”, may Allah be pleased with all of them. Is this a sign of deviation or not? (Some present answer) “Yes”. If they were upon truth and guidance, there would have been at least one companion with them. And regarding them (Daesh) we say the same thing, if it was any good in them, there would have been at least one firmly grounded scholar amongst them, and they do not have even one scholar with them. So beware of them O group of beloved ones, and I seek your pardon if I spoke too long, so pardon me. And what necessitated this was only that it was from advice, which is a right you have over me.

و صلى الله و سلم و بارك على نبينا محمد و على آله و صحبه و سلم

[1]: al-Qa’ed can also mean one who sits, so the Shaykh uses this parable regarding them.
[2]: Meaning the war against the Soviets in the late 70’s and early 80’s.
[3]: Sham here means Syria.
[4]: A branch of the Ithna ‘Ashariyyah sect of the Shi’a.
[5]: Referring to the battle of Tabuk which occurred at a time of extreme hardship due to the severe heat, the distance of Tabuk from al-Madinah and other factors. Uthman came with 1000 camels, 60 horses, 1000 dinars, and 10,000 Dirhams and he placed it in front of the Prophet (sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam).
[6]: The Rumah well was purchased by Uthman and is still present in Madinah until this very day.
[7]: Meaning the son witnessed the father pray along with the Muslims, so how can he claim they are Kuffar!
[8]: A stringed musical instrument similar to a guitar.
[9]: A cloak worn over the thawb.
Translation by Abu Suhayl Anwar Wright

Prophetic Guidelines for Protection And Safety from Trials and Misguidance – al-’Allaamah Rabee’ Ibn Haadee al-Madkhalee

lubaabbookIndeed, I advise myself and you with the taqwaa [1] of Allaah and ikhlaas (sincerity) [2] to Him and steadfastness upon the truth and holding fast to the Book and the Sunnah and that which the Salafus-Saalih were upon in terms of beliefs, acts of worship, manhaj (methodology) and moral character. I counsel you with these matters and advise that you give them the utmost importance.  You must direct your attention to them and form the mutual bonds of brotherhood amongst yourselves and you must inculcate mutual love amongst yourselves.  You must utilize the causes the mutual love, affection and unity and you must distance yourselves from stirring up trials and dilemmas.  And you must distance yourselves from the causes of disagreement amongst yourselves.  So such causes are many, so avoid them.

And strive to memorize the Book of Allaah and whatever you are able from the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) and study the books of the recognized people of knowledge as well as the writings of the recognized Imaams from the Imaams of the Sunnah.  And distance yourselves from the books of desires and misguidance, because many of those who follow up and read the likes of these books and audio recordings fall into deviations.

Indeed, the Salaf warned against such perils.  The books and audio recordings of fitan (trials, tribulations) and innovations cause many of the people to fall into errors and mistakes.  And the Salaf used to warn against the books of the people of misguidance.  Rather, the Companions (radiyallaahu ’anhum) burned some of the masaahif (written copies of the Qur‘aan) in order to unite the Ummah upon one mushaf.

So there are many fallacies and theories that many of the people use to deceive some of the youth.  One such fallacy is the statement that: We will read all of the books, including the books of misguidance and we will take the truth and abandon the falsehood from them.

And the reality is that this is a trap and an artifice set to ensnare the Salafee youth.  So the youth who does not have a firm grasp of the knowledge and he is not well versed in the Salafee manhaj, he becomes prone to error and deviation when he reads the books of the people of misguidance and falsehood.

And many of the youth have actually been deceived by this cunning statement.  So they begin to read and listen and the end result is deviation.

And the Messenger (’alayhis-salaatu was-salaam) advised that during the days of disagreements and splitting we must hold fast to his Sunnah and his guidance and the Sunnah and guidance of the Rightly Guided Caliphs.

And the individual will not obtain the knowledge of the Sunnah and guidance of the Prophet (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) and the guidance of the Rightly Guided Caliphs, except by exerting all of his effort in learning this Sunnah and this guidance and by turning his back to the statements of the dissenters and renegades.

So strive your utmost in learning the Sunnah and guidance of the Prophet (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) and hold fast to it and bite onto it with your molar teeth and beware of newly invented affairs, as our Prophet (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) has advised. [3] So by Allaah, this is the way to escape the trials and in it is the safety.  And that is the ark of salvation, may Allaah bless you.

So these are the Prophetic guidelines so revere and respect them.  And know that opposing them leads to deviation – and refuge is sought with Allaah.  Not being concerned with them, not giving them importance and not being mindful of them; all of that leads to deviation and falling into newly invented affairs.  So the individual is not safe from falling into the newly invented affairs, except if he holds fast to the Book of Allaah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) and the guidance of the Rightly Guided Caliphs (radiyallaahu ’anhum).

And that cannot occur, except by serious study and mindfulness and full comprehension of this Sunnah in the areas of ’aqeedah (creed), ’ibaadah (worship), manhaj (methodology) and in all fields of life.  And ignorance of that or carelessness in it leads to falling into innovations and misguidance, which are the newly invented affairs mentioned in the hadeeth, “And the most evil of affairs are the newly invented ones,” [4] as occurs in the hadeeth of Jaabir (radiyallaahu ’anhu) collected in Saheeh Muslim.

So it is upon you to take these advices and counsels and warnings from the noble Prophet (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) and with that our beliefs and methodologies and moral character will remain safe if Allaah so wills.

And I advise you to maintain amongst yourselves mutual friendship, mercy and affection.  And be zealous taking to the good and blessed means that bring about unity and love and distance yourselves from the causes of mutual hatred, jealousy, differing and whatever resembles that from that which has occurred amongst many of the youth.

Hold fast to calling to Allaah the Glorified and Exalted with wisdom and a good admonition.  Call the people: people of innovation and desires and partisanship and the Jews and the Christians and other than them.  Call them to Allaah with wisdom and a good admonition and proofs and evidence.  “That Allaah guides a single man through you is better for you than red camels.” [5]

And strive to be upon steadfastness with regards to this magnificent manhaj in the manner to which we have alluded.  And strive to guide the people.  And that cannot occur, except if you first arm yourselves with knowledge and arm yourselves with the wisdom, which is accompanied by proof and evidence.

And the people are in dire need of this goodness, which is exemplified by the Salafee manhaj, which emanates from the Book of Allaah and from the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allaah (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam).  And if the Muslims were to hold fast to this manhaj in truth, then you would surely see many people from these nations accepting Islaam and taking to it.

However, many of the Muslims who live amongst the Europeans and the Americans and others than them have deviations in their beliefs, their acts of worship, their moral character and in the rest of their dealings.  These deviations have disfigured the image and beauty of Islaam and they have run the people away.  If they were to present the real image of Islaam to the people, then you would see how they would rush to accept Islaam.

However, we say with great regret, as it was said by other than us: The Muslims have distorted Islaam and have run the enemies of Islaam away from it and from themselves.  That goes back to the ignorance or misguidance that many are living in from the sects that become widespread in those lands and it is due to the evil dealings and evil moral character which gives others a distorted view of Islaam.  So exemplify Islaam, as it is said.  And implement Islaam as a Religion and a creed and moral code of behaviour.  If Allaah so wills, Allaah will guide many of the enemies of Islaam, such as the Christians and the Jews at your hands.  Likewise, people will turn from all direction towards the truth the correct path, from those who are currently deviated by these sects within which you live and work and about whom many of you have complained.

We ask Allaah to unite between our hearts and to take us by our forelocks to the truth and to goodness.  Indeed, our Lord hears the supplication. [6]


[1]: Translator’s Note: Talq Ibn Habeeb (d.100H) – rahimahullaah – said, “Taqwaa is acting in obedience to Allaah, hoping in His mercy, upon guidance from Him; and taqwaa is leaving acts of disobedience to Allaah out of fear of Him, upon guidance from Him.”  Related by Ibn Abee Shaybah in Kitaab al-Eemaan (no. 99).  It was declared saheeh by al-Albaanee in his checking of the same book.

[2]: Translator’s Note: Shaykh al-Islaam Ibn Taymiyyah (d.728H) – rahimahullaah – said, “Due to this, the Imaams of the Salaf (rahimahumullaah) had a consensus upon these two fundamental principles.  So al-Fuḍayl Ibn ’Iyaad (d.187H) commented concerning the statement of Allaah the Blessed and Exalted, “So that He may test which of you is best in deed.” [Sooratul-Mulk 67:2] He said, “It is that which is most sincere and most correct.”  So it was said, “O Abaa ’Alee!  What is most sincere and most correct?”  So he replied, ‘The deed that is correct but not sincere is not accepted.  And if it is sincere but not correct, then it is likewise not accepted; not until it is both sincere and correct.  And sincere means that it must be done only for the sake of Allaah and correct means that it must be in accordance to the Sunnah.”  Refer to Majmoo’ al-Fataawaa (3/124) of Ibn Taymiyyah.

[3]: Translator’s Note: This is an allusion to the well-known hadeeth: From al-’Irbaad Ibn Saariyah (radiyallaahu ’anhu) who said: The Messenger of Allaah (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) admonished us with an intense sermon which caused the hearts to tremble and the eyes to shed tears, so we said, “O Messenger of Allaah!  It seems that this is a farewell sermon, so advise us.”  He replied, “I advise you with the fear of Allaah and to listen and obey even if the one granted authority over you is a slave.  So whoever lives long amongst you will see many disagreements.  So hold fast to my Sunnah and the way of the Rightly Guided Caliphs after me.  Bite onto that with your molar teeth and beware of the newly invented affairs, since every innovation is misguidance.”  Related by Aboo Daawood (no. 4607) and at-Tirmidhee (no. 2676), Ibn Maajah (no. 42-43).  It was declared saheeh by al-Albaanee in Saheehul-Jaami’ (no. 2549).

[4]: Related by Muslim (no. 867), from the hadeeth of Jaabir Ibn ’Abdullaah (radiyallaahu ’anhu).

[5]: Related by al-Bukhaaree (no. 2942) and Muslim (no. 2406), from the hadeeth of Sahl Ibn Sad (radiyallaahu ’anhu).

[6]: Refer to al-Lubaab min Majmoo’ Nasaa‘ih wa Tawjeehaat ash-Shaykh Rabee’ lish-Shabaab (p.275-279), the al-Miraathun-Nabawee printing.

Translation by Maaz Qureshi

Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Haadee al-Madkhalee: You Want to Save Him, But He wants to Revile You by Saying: You Have Nothing but Refutations!

The Noble Scholar, al-’Allaamah Muhammad Ibn Haadee al-Madkhalee – hafidhahullaah – said,


“So this is the obligation upon us with regards to him.  Whenever he refutes to clarify the error and to decrease the numbers of those who fall into it and to have mercy upon the one who has erred so that no one else will follow him in that error, then his right upon us is that we honour him, not that we revile him for it.

Now the opposite occurs in these days.  The refutations are not widely spread amongst many of the people!  Instead, war is waged against the correct Sharee’ah legislated refutations, which clarify the truth and guide the creation to the command of Allaah the Blessed and Most High!  ‘They do not have anything but refutations, refutations, refutations, refutations, refutations,’ they give utterance to this speech!!

And they do not realize that these refutations:

  • Safeguard the Religion of Allaah;
  • Protect the creation of Allaah.

So the Religion of Allaah is safeguarded from distortion, and the creation of Allaah are protected from falling into what?  Into the tahreef (distortion) of the corrupt individuals and into the blunders and into following the swindlers.

So if these people (i.e. who criticize the refutations) knew the reality: the advantages and benefits that result from the refutations, they would not utter such speech.

Due to this, the people who have the largest share in this topic are the Scholars.  Due to that, they have carried out this obligation by themselves with the best undertaking.  So you will find their refutations upon the people of error, falsehood and desire from the earliest days and they have books written in that regard.

Rather, many of the books of ’aqeedah (creed) authored by Ahlus-Sunnah were only written due to the deviation of the people of innovation.  So there was a need to clarify the Sunan in all of these issues and positions and to refute whosoever opposed them.

The Difference Between Sincere Advice and Revilement - al-Haafidh Ibn Rajab al-Hanbalee (d.795H)
The Difference Between Sincere Advice and Revilement – al-Haafidh Ibn Rajab al-Hanbalee (d.795H)

Therefore, the right of these people who write Sharee’ah legislated refutations is that they be honoured, respected and venerated, not that they be reviled.  So they have acted charitably towards us by safeguarding for us our Religion and safeguarding us, but we have acted in an evil manner towards them by reviling them and defacing their images and reputations and by running the people away from them.  So this, by Allaah is an unjust recompense.  So the likes of him and the likes of you are as the speaker said, “I want him to live, but he wants me to be killed.”

So you want for him to be safe from falling into deviation and going astray, but he wants to fight you by reviling you amongst the people and defacing your reputation and running the people away from you by saying, “They have nothing but refutations!”  It is as if refutations are now thought of as unfounded and disgraced!  We ask Allaah for protection and safety.” [1]


[1]: Taken from the fourth lesson of Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Haadee’s explanation of the book, al-Farq baynan-Naseehah wat-Ta’yeer, of Ibn Rajab (d.795H), which was part of the sessions conducted at the eleventh religious seminar held at the ’Utbah Ibn Ghazwaan mosque in Dammam, Saudi Arabia.

Translation by Maaz Qureshi

Shaykh Muhammad Ibn Haadee al-Madkhalee Disproves the False Principle: Do not Refute Them Until you Know What They Meant

[fap_track id=”3631″ layout=”list” enqueue=”no” button_enqueue=”no”]

ibnhadi[Q]: This questioner says: We have heard those who ascribe to as-Salafiyyah have formed a principle in refuting the innovator, “Do not refute him up until you know what he meant and up until you are a Scholar and so on.”  So what is the response to this?

[A]: I say: As for knowledge being a condition for the refutation, then yes.  You heard about it not too long ago.

As for the statement that you cannot refute someone up until you know what he meant, then this is speech which is in need of further detailed speech.

If his statement is apparently falsehood, then I must ask him about what he meant?!  He is only to be asked about something that is ambiguous.  As for that which is clear falsehood, then it is necessary to refute it.

If you are from those who are fit to refute and you are asked about that, or it has been obligated upon you, such that there is no one else to absolve you of this task, then it is obligatory upon you to clarify.  And we have not been commanded to investigate into the meanings of the people.  We have been commanded to take the people at face value.  The Prophet (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) said,

“I am only a human being, and you people have disputes. May be someone amongst you can present his case in a more eloquent and convincing manner than the other, and I give my judgment in his favour according to what I hear. Beware! If ever I give somebody something of his brother’s right then he should not take it as I have only, given him a piece of Fire…” [1]

And he (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) said to Usaamah Ibn Zayd (radiyallaahu ’anhumaa),

“Did you tear open his heart?”

This was when the man stated that there is no one worthy of worship besides Allaah, but Usaamah killed him, as Usaamah had been standing over him with the sword, so he killed him.  Usaamah replied,

“He only said it as a means of seeking protection.”

The Prophet said,

“Did you tear open his heart?” [2]

So he did not know what was inside the man’s chest and he was not held responsible for it.  He was held responsible for what was apparent.  And ’Umar (radiyallaahu ’anhu), the Leader of the Believers, said, as occurs in al-Bukhaaree,

“During the time of Prophethood, people accepted the Revelation.  As for now, then the Revelation has ceased…”

The Messenger of Allaah (sallallaahu ’alayhi wa sallam) had died.

“We only take the people at face value.  We bring close and favour the one who manifests goodness in front of us.  And we dismiss and distance ourselves from the one who manifests evil in front of us,” or as he – rahimahullaah – said. [3]

So we have not been commanded to investigate into the intended meanings.  Whosoever has speech that is falsehood, then falsehood must be refuted.  And if he is ignorant and he says, “I meant such and such, but I erred in the expression,” we reply, ‘The praise is for Allaah.  Therefore, you have corrected yourself.  So it is not permissible for anyone, from this point onwards, to follow you in that falsehood now that you are aware of it.’

So now you – O critic – have benefited the people firstly and him (i.e. the speaker of falsehood) secondly.

This speech (i.e. that you cannot refute someone up until you know what he meant) is incorrect.” [4]


[1]: Related by al-Bukhaaree (no. 2291), Muslim (no. 3237), Aboo Daawood (no. 3115), Ibn Maajah (no. 2310), at-Tirmidhee (no. 1256), an-Nisaa‘ee (no. 5683) and Ahmad in al-Musnad (no. 26016).

[2]: Related by Muslim (no. 140) and Aboo Daawood (no. 26430).

[3]: Related by al-Bukhaaree (no. 2498) and Ahmad in al-Musnad (no. 288).

[4]: Taken from the recorded gathering entitled, “Thawaabit ’Aadoo ilat-Tashkeek feehaa.”

Translation by Maaz Qureshi